Pennine Way Blog 3 – Days 4 – 6

The Purposeless Pennine Way, Episode Two, in which while meditating on the subversive pointlessness of repeating an experience, for the first time ever on the Pennine Way someone buys me a beer.

Something of a Philosophical Pennine Way. Practical Pennine Ways are also available, both south to north and north to south.

csairn on fountains fell yorkshire dales england

Back to more typical Pennine Way conditions!

Really I’ve no idea why I decided once more to walk the Pennine Way. Reaction to the announcement was muted: ‘I hope you’re not going to start obsessing about rucksacks again’. Factually harsh as of all the men you’ll meet on an upland trail I am the least obsessive about gear; my rucksack was a lucky second-hand find on eBay. But fair in spirit, I suppose, from someone heading out into the rain to dig potatoes, by herself.

I was going to call this account The Pointless Pennine Way, but that seemed, although factually fair, harsh in spirit. ‘Point’ is more negative – “what’s the point of all this?” implies that there’s no point, whereas “what’s the purpose of all this?” very much implies that there is a purpose, though possibly hidden. I had triggers: the TV programme and the cheap train. I had tactical targets: the three summits on which I’d not slept. I had a hankering for hills: living among the subtle topography of Norfolk I miss elevation and I hadn’t found the Hebridean Way very uplifting either physically or psychologically. I had timing: I first walked the Pennine Way in 1999 a few weeks before I turned forty, I liked the temporal elegance of repeating it just before I turn sixty. We’ll see whether I again repeat it just before I turn eighty!

snow mountain winter walking pennine way

Cross Fell, April 1999. Photo by Ronald Turnbull.

Otherwise, I was determined not any impose any strategic purpose on this modest exploit. It would be just for fun, and whichever type of fun came along. The facts of the trail might be harsh – I’ve never yet walked the Pennine Way without almost blubbing at some point – but my spirit would be set fair and fancy-free. Clearly it would have outcomes on multiple levels, some predictable, but I felt that to identify and anticipate these in advance might constrain their potential. A useful excuse as I’m temperamentally averse to planning of any kind; my life trajectory has always had a dominant random component.

I decided to blunder up The Way as blindly as might be consistent with actual survival, making no itinerary and booking absolutely nothing, expecting only sore feet and sheep. As it turned out my feet were fine, so even that expectation was confounded. There were sheep.

mug of tea and yorkshire ginger parking hebden bridge

World-class breakfast at May’s Shop

Day Four – May’s Shop to Pinhaw Beacon

They’d put the flags out for me on Clough Head Hill. As I was already feeling celebratory after a world-class breakfast of tea and sticky ginger parkin at May’s I tried to interpret them as a gift, and benignly to accept their high-vis plastic intrusion into what’s otherwise, after a long interlude of farmland, a welcome return to some enjoyably bleak moors.

flags on the pennine way national trail england yorkshire

Strange plastic flags all along the trail, goodness knows why.

I was further cheered by recalling how in April 1999 I’d trudged through bitterly cold slush up here, my feet freezing in my leaky boots. That, then, was grim old-school fellwalking, this now was a dry, sunny morning stroll. The only fly in the ointment was that it was far too early for the Packhorse Inn to be open. I’ve heard elsewhere that it’s still in business, and still great.

The Walshaw Dean reservoirs were extraordinarily low. ‘Seen ’em lower’, said a dog walker, ‘and this is when they drag out the stolen cars. And the bodies.’ It was very peaceful and with the rhythm of the easy walking I fell into a world of my own. I jumped out of my skin when a fellrunner suddenly came charging down Lower Fold Hill, and he then bagged a double- double-take when on turning around and running back up, he hilariously made me jump again.

top withins wuthering heights bronte country haworth yorkshire

Ugly signage has returned to Top Withins, let’s hope it falls apart soon. At least it’s informative this time, not just ‘health and safety’.

Even Top Withins had but a handful of visitors, although I could see from the path ahead that there’d be at least a dozen people there by ten o’clock.

wuthering heights bronte country yorkshie pennine way

The very useful bad weather shelter at Top Withins was once more accessible.


…although a bit draughty. One of those signs would fit this hole perfectly…

The lovely house at Upper Heights was for sale; if only I’d had £650,000, I could have bought it and re-opened the former much-loved campsite.

The vistas were broad, the air was still, the temperature benign; nothing whatsoever happened to me other than on the way up Old Bess Hill I picked up a revoltingly-perfumed sweatshirt which I waved like a knight’s banner on my pole at a group of teenagers ahead. Surprisingly they all denied it belonged to them, although I suspect one of their number was secretly embarrassed at a terrible fragrance selection error in a cheap chemist. It’s probably still up there making the sheep sneeze as I write.

ickornshaw mnoor on the pennine way england

Old-school waymarking, the new minimal marker post on the skyline (right).

The trend for minimalism and decluttering has reached Ickornshaw Moor where the motley cluster of sticks that used to decorate the summit has been simplified down to a single, slim pole which I should think is much less visible in fog.

pennine way hiking trail england

The newly-minimalised summit marker on Ickornshaw Moor

I was delighted for the first time ever to find one of the huts open and a denizen in residence; he told me all about them. The inherited rights exercised by the ‘freeholders’ who own these huts include a little sporting, rough Grouse shooting but by common agreement no birds had been taken this year as their productivity in the dry summer had been so poor. Later in the pub I was told that no Ickornshaw Grouse are eaten locally as they’re much too valuable. For the price of one sustainable free-range wild Grouse you can buy bags of imported, frozen battery chicken, all the chips and a six-pack or several too.

At Low Stubbing I met more shooters in camouflage, Dad and Grandad inculcating a young lad with ‘country ways’ and carrying in lieu of a Grouse the largest wild mushroom I’d ever seen, “great for breakfast”. They confirmed a disturbing rumour my trail antennae had already picked up, that there was no food at the refurbished Hare and Hounds.

On arrival I tried really hard not to argue with the new landlord about this; he was very friendly, his ale was excellent and more to the point I was dependent on him for the crisps and ‘spicy bar bits’ that were the only nutriment on sale. It was baffling, though, to me as a former owner of a rural hospitality business to see that they’d spent a fortune revamping the cosmetic appearance of the place to arguably negligible commercial benefit while sabotaging a previously functional kitchen that could have been printing them money. An alternative for food at Lothersdale is the Raygill Fish Farm along the road to the west but according to the website this is only open Friday, Saturday and Sunday and closes early.

pennine way yprkshire pinhaw beacon wild camp

Camped on Pinhaw Beacon above the duck pools. These were noisily infested with foolish ducks that clearly hadn’t twigged their sinister purpose.

Distressed at Lothersdale’s formerly famous suet puds having been condemned to the dustbin of professional hospitality evolution, I trudged up Pinhaw Beacon in unusually low spirits. These were lifted by my discovery of an excellent little camping nook near the summit, overlooking the duck pools. I failed to realise that sleeping here would involve quacking ducks, both at dusk and before dawn. Lots of quacking ducks. Also midges – it was time to retreat into my allegedly midge-proof inner tent, albeit with confidence as it was sold to me as such by a Scotsman. If there’s a people on this planet that should know about midge-proofing it’s that noble race of mossie-fodder.

The lack of food at the pub meant I had to resort to Supernoodles, enhanced by more of Ainsley’s mushroom gloop and an extra packet of crisps that, due to poor command of his expensive computerised ’till’ (sorry, electronic point of sale system), complete with touch screen and pictures of every item of merchandise, the landlord had been forced to give me as change.

camp cooking on the pennine way trail england

Camp food at its finest.

Day Five – Pinhaw Beacon to Malham

pennine way yorkshire dales

Dawn from Pinhaw Beacon

I awoke feeling uncharacteristically gloomy. I was lonely and cold and could not for the life of me work out why I’d chosen to do this walk again when I could be at home with my loved one. I was pushing sixty and getting stiff in the mornings, my silly old eyes could hardly see in the poor light of a wild camping dawn. All in all, was long distance walking still really, sensibly, come on now, my thing?


A bit teasy on the Beacon

Also dampening my spirits was the imminent walk through Cravendale, where the dairy farming is historically intensive and the ecology commensurately tragic.


Intensively fertilised rye grass, shaved almost to bare soil at least twice a year. Where’s a Lapwing or Curlew to even hide, let alone nest, in this?

cravendale haylage

The haylage, which is pretty much seedless so unlike traditional hay provides zero bird food, is left to dry a little then raked up and baled in plastic by huge and terrifying machines. Yes, the system depends on plastic.

There’s nothing like a slap-up breakfast in The Dalesman at Gargrave to cheer me up, so I duly had one, even though I had to wait forty minutes for it to open at ten on a Sunday morning. After the Hebridean Way I say ‘well done’ to The Dalesman for opening on Sunday at all. A sweet little old lady at the next table was visiting her son’s farm. Chatting, she told me she’d recently starting growing ‘a few of those little carrots’. Envisioning her pottering around a cottage garden, Yorkie at her heels, I said “oh yes, they grow lots of those in Norfolk”. “I grow some of mine down there”, she said, “this year in Norfolk I rented about six thousand acres”.


The old PW sign outside The Dalesman

The walk from Gargrave to Malham is a doddle, of course, and along the river it’s even a treat in fine weather.


Pretty Airedale. No, not a dog…

airedale malham yorkshire dales england

Aire Head, where the river springs mysteriously from the ground.

pennine way sign malham yorkshire

If you photographed all the lovely vintage signs on the Pennine Way it would take you a year to walk it.


Approaching Malham

It was a fine Sunday afternoon so, surprise surprise, Malham was absolutely jam-packed, rammed and chock-a-block with people, their vast array of cars on the parking field gleaming in the sunshine for miles. After a restorative tea and curd cake at The Old Barn I walked through wave after wave of tourists returning from the cove to the campsite where, sentimentally, I pitched my tent in exactly the same place my partner and I had camped two years ago.  Making exactly the same mistake of pitching by a damp, midgy river that I swore two years ago I wouldn’t make next time, given that there were drier, airier pitches at the top of the site.

The Lister Arms was so busy I tried the Buck Arms instead and ended up preferring it, less pretentious, less claustrophobic on a summer evening. I ordered a trio of sausages, imagining for some reason they would be wheeled in playing small musical instruments. All three were exceptionally delicious. The campsite was quiet, the shower was hot, my socks dried somewhat in the breeze. I felt a little better.

I’ve mentioned my concern at how an outdoors blog effectively imposes purpose on every trail I walk. This time I very much wanted the trail to wag the blog, not the blog wag the trail. I was almost tempted to let the entire exploit sink unreported into the river of time, discarding the virtual ‘postcards’ I send from the trail to Facebook for family and friends as if they were a virtual sand mandala (I have briefly tried blogging from the trail, but it was far too time- and battery-hungry). And what kind of boring, purposeless fool blogs about the same trail three times?

Munching my triyumyumyumvirate of sausages in the Buck Arms, I realised this third time lucky repetition could in fact serve my indirect purpose as a writer. I’ve fulfilled my duty to the outdoor community by producing two practical Pennine Way blogs with resource and navigation data. Now, back on the same trail but with job done, time served, factual blogs posted, I was liberated from having to take accurate notes and free to think whatever crazy thoughts I chose. Also to invent words.

How this might enable my trail writing to evolve I’m still not sure, but at least this time my lame, clunky flights of fancy could crash and burn into the peat. I didn’t need to pick them out and polish them, because I might not even bother to write them down. Perhaps jettisoning the lifebelt of purpose would leave me bobbing along the trail on a sinking ship of interesting whimsical introspection. A trail without a purpose is like a pie without a hat, like a sausage trio con brio, an armless buck, that kind of thing.

Day Six – Malham to Horton in Ribblesdale

This day started nicely, I’d slept well, the weather was dry. At the top of the cove, though, there was a very noisy group of people, locked in endless complicated and loud discussions that had nothing to do with their present extraordinary location, and at seven in the morning. Ah well, I had a squashed sandwich from Gargrave Co-Op for breakfast.

yorkshire dales england

Squashed sandwich brekkie above Malham Cove. Still dry at this point!

malham cove yorkshire dales england limestone

The incredible mammoth molars of the limestone pavement


pennine-way-from-malham-coveI thought all the famous flowers at Malham Tarn would be long over but I’d failed to anticipate a gorgeous display of Grass of Parnassus, lots of blooms.


Grass of Parnassus Parnassia palustris

It was clouding over, and as I rounded the back of the Field Centre it started to rain.


Clouding over, oo-er..

I was walking in t-shirt and shorts and as I ascended Fountains Fell I chose to simply pull waterproofs on over these as the rain became steady. This was a mistake. By the top cairn, things were quite unpleasant.

csairn on fountains fell yorkshire dales england

The topmost cairn on Fountains Fell, pouring with rain and much colder.

I was dismayed. The plan had been to camp out on Penyghent, the next of my two unslept summits. I’d imagined a pleasant afternoon fossicking around up there, a little light exploring, a leisurely Supernoodle supper.  But I’d be up there by two in the afternoon and the rain was teeming down with no sign of stopping. What on earth would I do up there for sixteen hours in pouring rain?


Views of Penyghent were unextensive…

No photos exist of this ascent of Penyghent. The rain hammered down, my phone would have been ruined in seconds. I climbed the steep bit, which resembled a vertical stream, following a northern lad of asian heritage in football shorts and the kind of black anorak you see on market stalls, unzipped. “I think I might buy some waterproofs”, he said on the top, still with his hood down, “I quite like this hillwalking”. His enviably dark and thick hair was, I suspect, slightly stiffened with one of those products young people spend fortunes on; each spikelet was crowned with a globule of water, he looked as if his head was covered in those little silver balls we used to put on fairy cakes as children.

A completely soaked couple of my own age (“yes, we’ve got to that point you get to when your waterproofs are useless but you’re just past caring”) imparted terrible news. The Pen-y-Ghent Café seemed to be closed! No! Impossible! What about my pint of tea and my buttered Chorley cake? Ridiculous.

Perhaps with the shock of this news, I suddenly felt very cold and I literally jogged down quite a lot of the big new stone steps and the interminable drove road. Even with this effort I failed to warm through, I realised too late I should have stopped and put on proper trousers and a warmie top way back at Malham Tarn. Not only was I soaking wet, I’d acquired some pretty bad chafing from the Gore-tex overtrousers rubbing my bare legs, a schoolboy error.

At Horton the café was indeed closed, I could hardly believe it. I made for the campsite which was itself in a state of slight crisis as Chris its proprietor had been hospitalised with heart trouble. I pitched the tent on soaking wet grass and lingered gratefully under a hot shower. Luckily the Golden Lion opens at three, so having warmed my muscles I could retreat there to warm my cockles.

The young chap who now manages this pub (very well) once camped wild on the west coast of Scotland for two months, living off the land. He had to call it off, he said, looking meaningfully at me, because his companion got hypothermia. The food in here is charmingly old school, they still serve a steak and ale pie that’s actually a bowl of (very good) stew with a spurious free-floating puff pastry hat perched on top. Bizarre. I prefer a more formally constructed pie myself but I wasn’t about to moan, it was delicious.


Pen-y-Ghent Café disaster!

A remarkable thing happened in the Golden Lion; an Irishman, who with impressive dedication to fashion was section-hiking The Way with Waltonesque dungarees in his pack as evening wear, bought me a beer. This has never happened before, not on the Pennine Way I mean, obviously it’s often happened in Ireland. I feel bad about this because not only did I slope off to bed without buying him one back (I did warn him this was likely) but I’d criminally misled him on the price of the pub’s cosy bunkhouse, which he’d asked me about after also descending soaked and frozen from Penyghent.

I told him from memory it was twenty-something pounds, on hearing which he decided to camp, damply. Imagine my shame (and annoyance after also pitching a tent to economise) on finding it was only twelve pounds, the twenty-something I’d remembered paying on my previous visit had been for two people. I chose not to confess this during our entertaining conversation, and if those sins of omission aren’t enough I’ve also forgotten his name. Apologies, dale buddy, and thanks, I enjoyed the beer. And your company. Not necessarily in order of importance.

“Why the Pennine Way again? Surely you should be ticking off some other trail from the list?” I’m a trail walker, not a trail collector. I’ve done one new trail already this year, so there, I get the rest of the year off for good behaviour. I like the Pennines. There’s a ridiculous superabundance of trails and I’m in my sixtieth year, I’ll never do them all. To try and choose another purely on grounds of neophilia seems both invidious and hazardous. On what criteria? Not everything in life has to be novel, any more than it has to be purposeful.

There’s also a ridiculous superabundance of outdoor blogs. I write mine for fun, because I like writing. It also gives me back the gift of a vaguely coherent souvenir of my own unimpressive adventures. I’ve never been able to keep up a journal on paper, but I find blogging strangely congenial and the feedback is nice (thank you).

The blogs I least enjoy are the most blatantly purposeful, such as those dispensing weekly slabs of the generic second-hand ‘advice’ that wastes the first twenty pages of every trail guide. I’ve observed an inverse correlation between the number of listings*, ‘top ten blog’ awards and endorsements that trail these blogs like diesel fumes and the novelty and quality of the ‘advice’. I’m also suspicious of outdoor blogs by young female ‘adventurers’, often ‘ambassadresses’ for upscale gear brands I’ve never heard of, who seem to spend all their time outdoors wearing impractically tiny shorts and coincidentally have about forty thousand followers. Strangely, you never encounter one of these gilded creatures when you’re splodging through a bog in gathering dusk and a relentless hoolie, and could do with a bit of glamour to cheer you up.

Yes, I’m wary of the overtly purposeful, and I realise now that goes for trail walking as well as blogging. Sitting in the Golden Lion contemplating the ontology of stew in a hat, I was starting to understand how my motivations and rewards for both may be harder than I thought to disentangle. I was pleased I’d emphasised my purposelessness to myself by abandoning one of my objectives, mind you, that TV presenter would have camped on Penyghent in the rain. Obviously.

[…  There are many blogs I do like, before you dismiss me as a curmudgeonly solipsist. First-hand advice based on personal experience I’m always grateful for. Blogs of actual experts from which I’ve learned much include those by  Chris Townsend, Alex Roddie and the laconic, elusive legend Colin Ibbotson. I enjoy trail journals with plenty of photos and self-deprecating humour, favourites include James and Geoff.

And I like blogs in which outdoor exploits, not necessarily physically challenging or overtly adventurous, are seamlessly integrated into the narration and consideration of other aspects of thought and life. Favourites include Anabel, Stephanie and the enigmatic Natassia’s explorations of the art and existentialism of walking. If you’re enjoying The Purposeless Pennine Way (stranger things have happened) my friend JR’s blog has a different take on exactly the same trail walked at exactly the same time. As I’ve said before, there’s only one Pennine Way and that’s your own. …]

*My blog carries a TGO listing, but look at the other blogs on there and you’ll see why I’m proud of this, not to mention embarrassed –  they make me look like an idiotic amateur.


  1. Well, i’m glad you keep on writing, it’s very entertaining! And thanks for the mention (though gutted not to qualify for the glamour section 😉).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I had just picked up “Pennine Way” by Stuart Greig from the library for a bit of overseas hiking inspiration, and now I’ve come across your posts on it as well. Great to read your stories and see your photos.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you, glad you like them. It’s my favourite trail although it’s not everybody’s cup of tea 😉 All good wishes.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for the shoutout! I wish I had the discipline to write as much as you, I have so many long trips I just haven’t written about at all… and your stories are always entertaining too! I don’t read a lot of trip reports either… or I skim them to find details about river crossings and ignore everything else.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re welcome, I’d certainly be glad if you wrote more but then I have an unfair advantage being retired. Creating an authentic piece, even a trail journal, that you’ve reflected on and put your heart into is incredibly draining of time and spirit. I skim over any river crossings 😂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. A lot of rivers/streams here are glacier fed and kill people all of the time so I really fear them. I actually really need to write about my early season wonderland trail hike based on what you’re saying about reflection, as I cried making a sketchy crossing on the remnants of a broken bridge, then did plenty of reflecting after a man died the next week doing the same thing.

        So that’s inspiration to write more, thanks!

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Oh my. And you have bears. Feel like renaming my blog ‘an oldie in the playpark’. Stay safe x


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: